Individual skill

review-paper

Review an attached academic economics paper PDF with independent specialist audits and a complete evidence-grounded report, resume an interrupted paper review, or export a completed Reviewer report as PDF. Not for a summary, a rewrite, or proofreading alone.

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/SKILL.md

Read pinned source

Source commit e6ae89dbab1aa642392d813caebcce197844edff

What was checked

Matches the observed repository HEAD: Yes
Scanner rules are current: No
Repository scan complete: No
Skill scan complete: No
Observed behavior: Not checked yet
Last checked: Nov 6, 2026

These are observations at the recorded commit, not a guarantee of safety. Review the source before running it.

Install this skill

Choose an agent in your Stack or copy a command below. Commands fetch the pinned commit and copy only this skill directory. Existing destinations are refused. Copying a command does not install anything.

An install command is unavailable: current rules, complete repository and skill scans, an eligible behavior level and a permitted license are required.

Repository context

Repository stars (not skill ratings): 230
Repository last updated: Oct 29, 2026
License: MIT

Observed agent integration: No specific integration evidence. Standard SKILL.md installation does not imply verified compatibility.

codex Repository topic
economics Repository topic
paper-review Repository topic
research-tools Repository topic
research Derived category

Files and excerpt

File metadata and permitted, redacted excerpts come from the recorded scan. Source links are pinned to that commit.

Browse files

SKILL.mdcore · 7,191 bytes
SKILL.mdcore · 7,191 bytes
SKILL.mdcore · 7,191 bytes
SKILL.mdcore · 7,191 bytes
agents/openai.yamlasset · 219 bytes
references/orchestration.mddoc · 15,208 bytes
runtime/LICENSE.mddoc · 1,073 bytes
runtime/bundle_manifest.jsonasset · 5,708 bytes
runtime/config/reviewers.jsonasset · 6,126 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/abstract_conclusion_consistency_audit.txtdoc · 1,520 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/claim_evidence_audit.txtdoc · 2,029 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/crossref_audit.txtdoc · 1,697 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/data_availability_replication_audit.txtdoc · 2,858 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/design_randomization_audit.txtdoc · 2,695 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/economic_magnitude_audit.txtdoc · 1,926 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/editor_report.txtdoc · 19,849 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/finding_verifier.txtdoc · 2,115 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/grammar_audit.txtdoc · 1,834 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/identification_audit.txtdoc · 1,767 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/institutional_context_audit.txtdoc · 2,460 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/limitations_external_validity_audit.txtdoc · 1,270 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/literature_audit.txtdoc · 3,478 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/model_equation_audit.txtdoc · 1,808 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/numerical_audit.txtdoc · 4,525 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/parser_quality_audit.txtdoc · 8,699 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/power_multiple_testing_audit.txtdoc · 2,170 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/reference_audit.txtdoc · 1,620 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/reviewer_contract.txtdoc · 10,465 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/reviewer_selection.txtdoc · 5,177 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/robustness_audit.txtdoc · 2,119 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/sample_construction_audit.txtdoc · 2,432 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/source_consistency_audit.txtdoc · 4,631 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/theory_logic_audit.txtdoc · 2,259 bytes
runtime/requirements.txtdoc · 87 bytes
runtime/reviewer-guidance/paper-reviewer.mddoc · 8,124 bytes
runtime/schemas/editor_decisions.schema.jsonasset · 3,253 bytes
runtime/schemas/finding_verification.schema.jsonasset · 3,287 bytes
runtime/schemas/reviewer_output.schema.jsonasset · 13,529 bytes
runtime/schemas/reviewer_selection.schema.jsonasset · 1,527 bytes
runtime/scripts/build_editor_input.pyruns · 29,508 bytes
runtime/scripts/check_final_report.pyruns · 11,055 bytes
runtime/scripts/editor_decisions.pyruns · 11,188 bytes
runtime/scripts/evidence_registry.pyruns · 11,305 bytes
runtime/scripts/finding_verification.pyruns · 5,641 bytes
runtime/scripts/normalize_review_outputs.pyruns · 25,420 bytes
runtime/scripts/numerical_checks.pyruns · 10,736 bytes
runtime/scripts/pipeline_paths.pyruns · 1,729 bytes
runtime/scripts/prepare_work_environment.pyruns · 5,843 bytes
runtime/scripts/preprocess_pdf.pyruns · 150,657 bytes
runtime/scripts/render_prompts.pyruns · 4,789 bytes
runtime/scripts/render_report_pdf.pyruns · 14,741 bytes
runtime/scripts/review_acceptance.pyruns · 2,413 bytes
runtime/scripts/review_coverage.pyruns · 6,182 bytes
runtime/scripts/reviewer_config.pyruns · 5,965 bytes
runtime/scripts/reviewer_routing.pyruns · 8,286 bytes
runtime/scripts/strict_json.pyruns · 616 bytes
runtime/scripts/validate_review_json.pyruns · 14,542 bytes
runtime/scripts/work_plugin.pyruns · 52,286 bytes

Read excerpt


# Review this paper

Deliver the complete report as a downloadable **PDF**, with a brief plain-language
summary. Preserve the editor's `report.md` as the authoritative source and an optional
download; the PDF is a deterministic presentation, not a rewritten review.
Use **native ChatGPT Work subagents** for parser preflight, the applicability
router, each selected reviewer, and the editor. This skill explicitly requests that
delegation. The parent orchestrates and validates; only the editor authors the report.

## Start with the user experience

For a **PDF-only export of an existing completed Reviewer report**, go directly to
[PDF-first delivery](references/orchestration.md#pdf-first-delivery). Do not start
new audits, spend agent allowance, or resume an incompatible older checkpoint just