Not in the top 1,000 by GitHub stars

Ingar30/reviewer

History

Review weekly changes to SKILL.md before updating. Dates mark the weeks in which we observed each version; checks apply to the recorded commits.

View weekly changes

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/SKILL.md`

Week of Oct 26, 2026 · Line counts unavailable

Before Not checked yet → After Local scripts

First observation → e6ae89dbab1a

No earlier version was observed for comparison.

Compare on GitHub

View on GitHub Add to my skills

Verified commit e6ae89dbab1aa642392d813caebcce197844edff

Version-pinned installation · Codex

git clone --filter=blob:none --no-checkout https://github.com/Ingar30/reviewer.git .hotskills/ingar30-reviewer && git -C .hotskills/ingar30-reviewer checkout --detach e6ae89dbab1aa642392d813caebcce197844edff
# Copy each selected skill directory from .hotskills/ingar30-reviewer into .agents/skills/<skill-name>/

230GitHub stars

1star in 7 days

1skill in this repository

6commits in 30 days

Heat

2.9

Star growth, last 7 daysNot available
Star growth, last 24 hoursNot available
Rank movement, last 7 daysNot available
Commits, last 30 daysNot available
Accounts asking about it through MCP, last 7 daysNot available
Hot votes this weekNot available

Heat never changes the order by stars, and sponsorship never touches it. How heat works

Stars over time

30-day change not yet available: not enough history.

Individual skills in this repository

review-paper plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper

How it works

review-paper

When your agent uses it

Review an attached academic economics paper PDF with independent specialist audits and a complete evidence-grounded report, resume an interrupted paper review, or export a completed Reviewer report as PDF. Not for a summary, a rewrite, or proofreading alone.

What it loads into context

Frontmatter

53 tokens

Always available to the agent

SKILL.md

1,427 tokens

When the skill is activated

Reference documents

4,876 tokens

Loaded on request

Token counts are estimates. Scripts run separately; they are not counted as reference context.

The playbook

Start with the user experience
Adapt the execution host, not the methodology
Mode contract
Evidence and completion boundaries

Scripts executed separately

runtime/scripts/build_editor_input.py
runtime/scripts/check_final_report.py
runtime/scripts/editor_decisions.py
runtime/scripts/evidence_registry.py
runtime/scripts/finding_verification.py
runtime/scripts/normalize_review_outputs.py
runtime/scripts/numerical_checks.py
runtime/scripts/pipeline_paths.py
runtime/scripts/prepare_work_environment.py
runtime/scripts/preprocess_pdf.py
runtime/scripts/render_prompts.py
runtime/scripts/render_report_pdf.py
runtime/scripts/review_acceptance.py
runtime/scripts/review_coverage.py
runtime/scripts/reviewer_config.py
runtime/scripts/reviewer_routing.py
runtime/scripts/strict_json.py
runtime/scripts/validate_review_json.py
runtime/scripts/work_plugin.py
../../../../scripts/work_plugin.py

Files

SKILL.mdcore7,191 bytes
SKILL.mdcore7,191 bytes
SKILL.mdcore7,191 bytes
SKILL.mdcore7,191 bytes
agents/openai.yamlasset219 bytes
references/orchestration.mddoc15,208 bytes
runtime/LICENSE.mddoc1,073 bytes
runtime/bundle_manifest.jsonasset5,708 bytes
runtime/config/reviewers.jsonasset6,126 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/abstract_conclusion_consistency_audit.txtdoc1,520 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/claim_evidence_audit.txtdoc2,029 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/crossref_audit.txtdoc1,697 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/data_availability_replication_audit.txtdoc2,858 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/design_randomization_audit.txtdoc2,695 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/economic_magnitude_audit.txtdoc1,926 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/editor_report.txtdoc19,849 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/finding_verifier.txtdoc2,115 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/grammar_audit.txtdoc1,834 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/identification_audit.txtdoc1,767 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/institutional_context_audit.txtdoc2,460 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/limitations_external_validity_audit.txtdoc1,270 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/literature_audit.txtdoc3,478 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/model_equation_audit.txtdoc1,808 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/numerical_audit.txtdoc4,525 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/parser_quality_audit.txtdoc8,699 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/power_multiple_testing_audit.txtdoc2,170 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/reference_audit.txtdoc1,620 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/reviewer_contract.txtdoc10,465 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/reviewer_selection.txtdoc5,177 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/robustness_audit.txtdoc2,119 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/sample_construction_audit.txtdoc2,432 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/source_consistency_audit.txtdoc4,631 bytes
runtime/prompts/templates/theory_logic_audit.txtdoc2,259 bytes
runtime/requirements.txtdoc87 bytes
runtime/reviewer-guidance/paper-reviewer.mddoc8,124 bytes
runtime/schemas/editor_decisions.schema.jsonasset3,253 bytes
runtime/schemas/finding_verification.schema.jsonasset3,287 bytes
runtime/schemas/reviewer_output.schema.jsonasset13,529 bytes
runtime/schemas/reviewer_selection.schema.jsonasset1,527 bytes
runtime/scripts/build_editor_input.pyruns29,508 bytes
runtime/scripts/check_final_report.pyruns11,055 bytes
runtime/scripts/editor_decisions.pyruns11,188 bytes
runtime/scripts/evidence_registry.pyruns11,305 bytes
runtime/scripts/finding_verification.pyruns5,641 bytes
runtime/scripts/normalize_review_outputs.pyruns25,420 bytes
runtime/scripts/numerical_checks.pyruns10,736 bytes
runtime/scripts/pipeline_paths.pyruns1,729 bytes
runtime/scripts/prepare_work_environment.pyruns5,843 bytes
runtime/scripts/preprocess_pdf.pyruns150,657 bytes
runtime/scripts/render_prompts.pyruns4,789 bytes
runtime/scripts/render_report_pdf.pyruns14,741 bytes
runtime/scripts/review_acceptance.pyruns2,413 bytes
runtime/scripts/review_coverage.pyruns6,182 bytes
runtime/scripts/reviewer_config.pyruns5,965 bytes
runtime/scripts/reviewer_routing.pyruns8,286 bytes
runtime/scripts/strict_json.pyruns616 bytes
runtime/scripts/validate_review_json.pyruns14,542 bytes
runtime/scripts/work_plugin.pyruns52,286 bytes
../../../../scripts/work_plugin.pyruns52,286 bytes

Read SKILL.md


# Review this paper

Deliver the complete report as a downloadable **PDF**, with a brief plain-language
summary. Preserve the editor's `report.md` as the authoritative source and an optional
download; the PDF is a deterministic presentation, not a rewritten review.
Use **native ChatGPT Work subagents** for parser preflight, the applicability
router, each selected reviewer, and the editor. This skill explicitly requests that
delegation. The parent orchestrates and validates; only the editor authors the report.

## Start with the user experience

For a **PDF-only export of an existing completed Reviewer report**, go directly to
[PDF-first delivery](references/orchestration.md#pdf-first-delivery). Do not start
new audits, spend agent allowance, or resume an incompatible older checkpoint just

View the complete source on GitHub

Skills included

review-paper

Repository facts

License: MIT
Created: May 14, 2026
Last pushed: Oct 29, 2026
Forks: 47
Open issues: 2
Project activity: Active

Before you install

Local scripts

Automated signals, not a guarantee

Checked Nov 6, 2026

Not fully analyzed: some files were too long, unreadable or missing. This never lowers the level.

Show 3 notes

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/SKILL.md:1 Analysis incomplete: Referenced executable target unavailable; not analyzed
plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/SKILL.md:1 Analysis incomplete: Referenced executable target unavailable; not analyzed
plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/SKILL.md:1 Analysis incomplete: Referenced executable target unavailable; not analyzed

No broad tool permissions
No dangerous shell commands
3 network referencesin 1 file: review-paper/runtime/scripts/prepare_work_environment.py:74
No hidden or obfuscated text
No instruction overrides
20 executable scriptsin 20 files: review-paper/runtime/scripts/build_editor_input.py:1 review-paper/runtime/scripts/check_final_report.py:1 review-paper/runtime/scripts/editor_decisions.py:1 and 17 more
No access to secrets
No requests to vote in Hot

Show all 23 signals by file

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/build_editor_input.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/check_final_report.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/editor_decisions.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/evidence_registry.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/finding_verification.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/normalize_review_outputs.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/numerical_checks.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/pipeline_paths.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/prepare_work_environment.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

Network accessline 74

python = destination / ("Scripts/python.exe" if sys.platform == "win32" else "bin/python")     setup_command([str(python), "-I", "-m", "pip", "--isolated", "--disable-pip-version-check",                    "--no-input", "install", "--index-

Network accessline 75

setup_command([str(python), "-I", "-m", "pip", "--isolated", "--disable-pip-version-check",                    "--no-input", "install", "--index-url", "https://pypi.org/simple",                    "--only-binary=:all:", "--no-cache-dir", "-

Network accessline 76

"--no-input", "install", "--index-url", "https://pypi.org/simple",

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/preprocess_pdf.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/render_prompts.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/render_report_pdf.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/review_acceptance.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/review_coverage.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/reviewer_config.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/reviewer_routing.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/strict_json.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/validate_review_json.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/work_plugin.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

`scripts/work_plugin.py`

Executable scriptline 1
```
Executable file
```

How the signals fit together

Facts from a static read of the files at the pinned commit. They describe what the code does, not why.

Declared and executed: 1 fact

Contacts pypi.org, which SKILL.md, the README and the plugin manifest do not mentionreview-paper/runtime/scripts/prepare_work_environment.py:76High confidence

Signal confidence: 23 facts

Executable script in code of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/build_editor_input.py:1High confidence
Executable script in code of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/check_final_report.py:1High confidence
Executable script in prose of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/editor_decisions.py:1Low confidence
Executable script in prose of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/evidence_registry.py:1Low confidence
Executable script in prose of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/finding_verification.py:1Low confidence
Executable script in code of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/normalize_review_outputs.py:1High confidence
Executable script in prose of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/numerical_checks.py:1Low confidence
Executable script in code of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/pipeline_paths.py:1High confidence
Executable script in prose of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/prepare_work_environment.py:1Low confidence
Network access in code of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/prepare_work_environment.py:74High confidence
Network access in code of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/prepare_work_environment.py:75High confidence
Network access in code of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/prepare_work_environment.py:76High confidence
Executable script in code of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/preprocess_pdf.py:1High confidence
Executable script in code of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/render_prompts.py:1High confidence
Executable script in prose of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/render_report_pdf.py:1Low confidence
Executable script in prose of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/review_acceptance.py:1Low confidence
Executable script in prose of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/review_coverage.py:1Low confidence
Executable script in code of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/reviewer_config.py:1High confidence
Executable script in prose of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/reviewer_routing.py:1Low confidence
Executable script in prose of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/strict_json.py:1Low confidence
Executable script in code of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/validate_review_json.py:1High confidence
Executable script in prose of a file that runsreview-paper/runtime/scripts/work_plugin.py:1Low confidence
Executable script in prose of a file that runsscripts/work_plugin.py:1Low confidence

Works with

Agent compatibility, from the files in this repository
Agent	Status	Evidence	Install to
Claude Code	Compatible	Standard SKILL.md plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/SKILL.md	`.claude/skills/<skill-name>/`
Codex	Native	Manifest AGENTS.md	`.agents/skills/<skill-name>/`
Cursor	Compatible	Standard SKILL.md plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/SKILL.md	`.cursor/skills/<skill-name>/`
Gemini CLI	Compatible	Standard SKILL.md plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/SKILL.md	`.gemini/skills/<skill-name>/`
GitHub Copilot	Compatible	Standard SKILL.md plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/SKILL.md	`.github/skills/<skill-name>/`
OpenCode	Compatible	Standard SKILL.md plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/SKILL.md	`.opencode/skills/<skill-name>/`

Native The repository ships a manifest, folder or frontmatter field for this agent.
Compatible A standard SKILL.md that this agent can read.
Unknown No evidence either way.

Derived automatically from paths, manifests and frontmatter. Not tested on each agent.

Ingar30/reviewer

History

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/SKILL.md

Share this page

Heat

Stars over time

Individual skills in this repository

How it works

review-paper

Frontmatter

SKILL.md

Reference documents

The playbook

Scripts executed separately

Files

Skills included

Repository facts

Before you install

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/build_editor_input.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/check_final_report.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/editor_decisions.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/evidence_registry.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/finding_verification.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/normalize_review_outputs.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/numerical_checks.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/pipeline_paths.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/prepare_work_environment.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/preprocess_pdf.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/render_prompts.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/render_report_pdf.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/review_acceptance.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/review_coverage.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/reviewer_config.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/reviewer_routing.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/strict_json.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/validate_review_json.py

plugins/economics-paper-reviewer/skills/review-paper/runtime/scripts/work_plugin.py

scripts/work_plugin.py