Individual skill
science-rebuttal-playbook
Use immediately after receiving reviewer reports, when a revision decision says major revision, or when you disagree with a reviewer; covers the numbered-response structure, how to split fixable from arguable points, why unprincipled compliance backfires, and how to escalate a genuine disagreement to the editor.
dsh-science/skills/science/science-rebuttal-playbook/SKILL.md
Source commit 088b0228df4fbb613d00d70823a325677f4970c2
What was checked
- Matches the observed repository HEAD
- Yes
- Scanner rules are current
- Yes
- Repository scan complete
- No
- Skill scan complete
- Yes
- Observed behavior
- Instructions only
- Last checked
- Nov 10, 2026
These are observations at the recorded commit, not a guarantee of safety. Review the source before running it.
Install this skill
Choose an agent in your Stack or copy a command below. Commands fetch the pinned commit and copy only this skill directory. Existing destinations are refused. Copying a command does not install anything.
An install command is unavailable: current rules, complete repository and skill scans, an eligible behavior level and a permitted license are required.
Repository context
- Repository stars (not skill ratings)
- 973
- Repository last updated
- Oct 25, 2026
- License
- MIT
Observed agent integration: No specific integration evidence. Standard SKILL.md installation does not imply verified compatibility.
- agent-skills Repository topic
- cordis Repository topic
- deepseek-harness Repository topic
- literature-review Repository topic
- mcp Repository topic
- nodejs Repository topic
- reproducibility Repository topic
- research Repository topic
- scientific-writing Repository topic
- windows Repository topic
- legal Derived category
Files and excerpt
File metadata and permitted, redacted excerpts come from the recorded scan. Source links are pinned to that commit.
Browse files
SKILL.mdcore · 3,804 bytes
Read excerpt
# 审稿回应：先分类，再逐条
## 第一步：切条与分类（不要直接开始写）
把评审意见粘进 `science_rebuttal`，它会切成编号条目并按类型标注：
| 类型 | 特征用语 | 做法 |
|---|---|---|
| **new-experiment** | additional experiments / should test / in vivo | 能补就补；不能补降级为 limitation 并说明不影响主结论 |
| **statistics** | sample size / power / CI / multiple comparison | 一律重跑，给效应量 + 95% CI + 校正方法 |
| **claim-strength** | overclaim / not supported / too strong | 降低表述强度，并在讨论里给替代解释 |
| **prior-work** | should cite / already reported | 补引用并写清增量；确属已知就改成"确认并扩展" |
| **clarity** | unclear / confusing / rewrite | 重写该段，回应里引改后原句 + page/line |
| **method-detail** | provide more detail / reagent / version | 补到可复现粒度，移到 SI 并在正文加指引 |