s4h-writing-inconsistency-audit

• SKILL.mdcore · 8,252 bytes

# Writing: Inconsistency Audit

Inconsistencies undermine the reader's trust more efficiently than almost any other flaw — because they signal that the author lost track of their own world. The reader's contract with a story is: I will suspend disbelief in exchange for internal coherence. One visible inconsistency tells the reader the author may have lost the thread, and the reader will spend the rest of the story half-watching for the next crack rather than being inside the experience.

Four types of inconsistency require separate passes, because they operate at different levels and have different causes:

**Timeline inconsistency:** Events that are out of chronological order, time spans that don't add up, characters who are in two places at once, seasons that shift unexpectedly.

**Character logic inconsistency:** Characters who act contrary to their established psychology without earned cause, who know things they couldn't know, who forget things they must know, who respond to situations in ways their established temperament doesn't allow.

**World-rules inconsistency:** The story's established physics, magic, technology, or social rules that function differently in different scenes — usually because the plot needs them to.

**Physical continuity inconsistency:** Objects that change hands, locations, or appearance without explanation; characters whose physical description changes; room layouts that contradict themselves.