Individual skill
light-review
Review an author's completed or near-complete scientific manuscript, figures, tables, and supplements before submission, especially after light-write. Use for 投稿前内部评审、论文自审、模拟审稿、主张与证据审查、图文数值核对、投稿就绪检查 and revision rechecks. Produce located, evidence-grounded issues and a bounded repair plan. Initial writing, new experiments, figure production, and responses to received journal reviews belong elsewhere.
light-review/SKILL.md
Source commit 6597430ad09d8f7c3518ec4cb08829be2b417e18
What was checked
- Matches the observed repository HEAD
- Yes
- Scanner rules are current
- Yes
- Repository scan complete
- No
- Skill scan complete
- Yes
- Observed behavior
- Local scripts
- Last checked
- Nov 8, 2026
These are observations at the recorded commit, not a guarantee of safety. Review the source before running it.
Install this skill
Choose an agent in your Stack or copy a command below. Commands fetch the pinned commit and copy only this skill directory. Existing destinations are refused. Copying a command does not install anything.
An install command is unavailable: current rules, complete repository and skill scans, an eligible behavior level and a permitted license are required.
Repository context
- Repository stars (not skill ratings)
- 883
- Repository last updated
- Nov 7, 2026
- License
- MIT
Observed agent integration: No specific integration evidence. Standard SKILL.md installation does not imply verified compatibility.
- academic-writing Repository topic
- ai-agent Repository topic
- claude-code Repository topic
- codex Repository topic
- llm-skills Repository topic
- paper-writing Repository topic
- research-tools Repository topic
- scientific-workflow Repository topic
- agent-skills Repository topic
- ai-skills Repository topic
- writing Derived category
- research Derived category
Files and excerpt
File metadata and permitted, redacted excerpts come from the recorded scan. Source links are pinned to that commit.
Browse files
.gitignoreasset · 38 bytesREADME.mddoc · 6,463 bytesSKILL.mdcore · 10,007 bytesTHIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.mddoc · 1,070 bytesagents/openai.yamlasset · 400 bytesassets/report-template.mddoc · 1,965 bytesassets/review-record.template.jsonasset · 1,406 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06-upgrade.mddoc · 6,760 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/baseline-reproduction.jsonasset · 434 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/logs/calculate.jsonasset · 242 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/logs/freeze-1.jsonasset · 322 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/logs/freeze-2.jsonasset · 322 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/logs/freeze-3.jsonasset · 322 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/logs/reject-dropped-issue.jsonasset · 187 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/logs/reject-old-closure-stamp.jsonasset · 187 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/logs/review-validate-1.jsonasset · 443 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/logs/review-validate-2.jsonasset · 499 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/logs/review-validate-3.jsonasset · 499 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/logs/write-audit-1.jsonasset · 1,527 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/logs/write-audit-2.jsonasset · 1,790 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/logs/write-audit-3.jsonasset · 1,717 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/result.jsonasset · 1,198 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Analysis/AN-0001_descriptive/calculate.pyruns · 401 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Analysis/AN-0001_descriptive/results.jsonasset · 159 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Experiment/Data/sites.csvasset · 45 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0001_synthetic/packet/materials/M001-manuscript.mddoc · 280 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0001_synthetic/packet/materials/M002-sites.csvasset · 45 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0001_synthetic/packet/materials/M003-results.jsonasset · 159 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0001_synthetic/packet/materials/M004-calculate.pyruns · 401 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0001_synthetic/packet/packet.jsonasset · 1,601 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0001_synthetic/packet/review.stub.jsonasset · 2,268 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0001_synthetic/review.jsonasset · 4,774 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0001_synthetic/review.mddoc · 250 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0002_synthetic/packet/materials/M001-manuscript.mddoc · 335 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0002_synthetic/packet/materials/M002-sites.csvasset · 45 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0002_synthetic/packet/materials/M003-results.jsonasset · 159 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0002_synthetic/packet/materials/M004-calculate.pyruns · 401 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0002_synthetic/packet/packet.jsonasset · 1,601 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0002_synthetic/packet/review.stub.jsonasset · 2,268 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0002_synthetic/review.jsonasset · 4,960 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0002_synthetic/review.mddoc · 255 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0003_synthetic/attempts/dropped-issue.jsonasset · 4,069 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0003_synthetic/attempts/old-closure-stamp.jsonasset · 5,534 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0003_synthetic/packet/materials/M001-manuscript.mddoc · 390 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0003_synthetic/packet/materials/M002-sites.csvasset · 45 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0003_synthetic/packet/materials/M003-results.jsonasset · 159 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0003_synthetic/packet/materials/M004-calculate.pyruns · 401 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0003_synthetic/packet/packet.jsonasset · 1,601 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0003_synthetic/packet/review.stub.jsonasset · 2,268 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0003_synthetic/review.jsonasset · 5,534 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Review/REV-0003_synthetic/review.mddoc · 292 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Write/Paper-01_synthetic/drafts/v01/manuscript-packet.jsonasset · 1,433 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Write/Paper-01_synthetic/drafts/v01/manuscript.mddoc · 280 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Write/Paper-01_synthetic/drafts/v02/manuscript-packet.jsonasset · 1,560 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Write/Paper-01_synthetic/drafts/v02/manuscript.mddoc · 335 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Write/Paper-01_synthetic/drafts/v03/manuscript-packet.jsonasset · 1,610 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/exercise/synthetic-project/Write/Paper-01_synthetic/drafts/v03/manuscript.mddoc · 390 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/final-checks.jsonasset · 493 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/history-before.jsonasset · 758 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/light-anaysis-tests.logasset · 9,062 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/light-leader-tests.logasset · 5,689 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/light-review-tests.logasset · 7,758 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/light-write-tests.logasset · 6,785 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/run_revision_exercise.pyruns · 10,946 bytesevaluations/2026-11-06/test-summary.jsonasset · 1,356 bytesevaluations/REPORT.mddoc · 3,635 bytesevaluations/fixtures/case-a.mddoc · 1,890 bytesevaluations/fixtures/case-b.mddoc · 519 bytesevaluations/fixtures/case-c.mddoc · 1,077 bytesevaluations/record-exercise.jsonasset · 552 bytesevaluations/walkthroughs/case-a.mddoc · 4,050 bytesevaluations/walkthroughs/case-b.mddoc · 1,609 bytesevaluations/walkthroughs/case-c.mddoc · 1,309 bytesreferences/artifact-contract.mddoc · 14,004 bytesreferences/domain-gates.mddoc · 6,604 bytesreferences/figures-and-numbers.mddoc · 4,876 bytesreferences/handoff-and-recheck.mddoc · 5,920 bytesreferences/literature-and-venue.mddoc · 4,808 bytesreferences/project-integration.mddoc · 4,288 bytesreferences/project-layout.mddoc · 5,972 bytesreferences/review-method.mddoc · 5,397 bytesreferences/source-audit.jsonasset · 35,381 bytesreferences/sources.mddoc · 13,089 bytesscripts/review_packet.pyruns · 22,628 bytestests/test_review_packet.pyruns · 27,428 bytes
Read excerpt
# light-review
## 项目目录与续作
需要落盘或继续已有项目时,先读 [项目目录约定](references/project-layout.md),按其中的本阶段位置、版本与关联规则保存;用户指定路径和旧项目优先。包内资源相对本 skill,研究产物相对真实项目,二者不要混用。只做局部讨论时无需初始化目录。
持续项目先按 [项目接入](references/project-integration.md) 恢复有关 Memory、旧评审和采用版本,再核对真实稿件与科学原件。记忆、Workflow 完成状态和上游工具通过都不能代替本轮评审。
把已经写完、图表已经制作好的论文,变成**可定位、可修复、可复核的投稿前内部评审结果**。默认中文;按用户要求输出其他语言。适用于作者自审和团队内部预审,不冒充期刊决定,不预测录用概率。报告的价值取决于重要问题是否判断正确,不取决于意见数量或篇幅。
## 入口与按需阅读
| 用户任务 | 加载与执行 |
|---|---|